Accuracy: Biographer sticks to the facts; portrayal is supported by subject’s own writing; dates, names, and numbers are accurate
Setting and plot: Facts and story line are integrated; connections between the social climate and the individual’s accomplishments; social climate is honestly portrayed; plot revolves around authentic events
Portrayal of the subject: Character well developed; stereotypes avoided; person is a worthy subject; writer shows strengths and weaknesses; people around the subject developed adequately; their influence is accurately portrayed
Style: Comprehensible and engaging; complex topics explained adequately without oversimplifying
Theme: There is a unifying theme; writer characterizes the subject’s life; writer makes the subject memorable
Illustrations: Enrich the details; help visualize the time and place; portray authentic scenes